Saints’ Derek Carr to blame for Chris Olave’s concussion, according to Cam Newton

Saints’ Derek Carr to Blame for Chris Olave’s Concussion, According to Cam Newton

 

A recent comment from former NFL quarterback Cam Newton has sparked controversy and debate around the New Orleans Saints’ handling of star wide receiver Chris Olave’s recent concussion. Newton, known for his outspoken views, weighed in on the Saints’ passing game, pointing the finger at quarterback Derek Carr as a key factor in Olave’s injury.

 

Newton’s Take: A QB’s Responsibility

 

During a recent interview on his podcast, Newton discussed the Saints’ recent struggles on offense and particularly highlighted Derek Carr’s role in Olave’s concussion. According to Newton, Carr’s decision-making and positioning of the football may have left Olave more vulnerable to taking hard hits. “The quarterback has to protect his guys,” Newton stated. “When you throw into certain situations, you’re putting your receivers in harm’s way, and sometimes that leads to what we’re seeing with Olave.”

 

Newton’s comments center on a quarterback’s duty to throw in ways that minimize risk to receivers. He suggested that Carr’s ball placement on certain routes may have left Olave exposed to a defender, leading to the hit that caused the concussion. While Newton did not imply that Carr intentionally endangered Olave, he emphasized that quarterbacks must take extra care to avoid risky throws that could expose their receivers.

 

Carr’s Response and Saints’ Perspective

 

Derek Carr has not yet publicly responded to Newton’s comments, but the Saints organization has stood by their quarterback. The coaching staff and medical team have maintained that the team is dedicated to player safety and noted that concussions are an unfortunate reality of football, often unavoidable despite precautions.

 

The Saints have also highlighted that their play-calling and game-planning consider multiple factors, with player safety being paramount. A source within the team remarked, “Derek has been a leader on this team, and he’s very aware of his responsibility to his teammates. Injuries happen, and sometimes they’re unavoidable due to the nature of the sport.”

 

Analyzing Newton’s Criticism: Fair or Out of Line?

 

Newton’s remarks have sparked debate among fans, analysts, and former players. Some agree with Newton, arguing that Carr’s passes to Olave at times do appear to expose the receiver to high-impact hits, especially on routes over the middle. Critics believe Carr’s adjustments to avoid such situations could lower the injury risks for Olave and other receivers.

 

Others argue that Newton’s criticism oversimplifies a complex issue, noting that football is an inherently violent game and that no quarterback can fully prevent injuries. While quarterbacks aim to protect their receivers, the speed and split-second decisions required during plays make it challenging to control the aftermath of every throw. Moreover, defensive players often adjust their positions to anticipate where a quarterback might pass, making it nearly impossible to avoid dangerous collisions.

 

Impact on Team Dynamics and Olave’s Recovery

 

Newton’s comments have added pressure on Carr, who is already under scrutiny amid the Saints’ up-and-down season. As Carr works to refine his connection with Olave and other Saints receivers, these critiques may increase the scrutiny on his passing choices and field awareness.

 

Meanwhile, the Saints medical team is focused on Olave’s recovery and ensuring he follows the concussion protocol thoroughly. As one of the Saints’ most talented and reliable targets, Olave’s health is essential to the team’s offensive success, and the organization is taking a careful approach to bring him back when he’s fully ready.

 

Looking Ahead: Will This Affect Carr and the Saints?

 

Newton’s comments may add to the pressure Carr faces as he looks to guide the Saints into a playoff position. Some fans and analysts worry that Carr might feel the need to be overly cautious, potentially impacting his decision-making and altering the team’s offensive rhythm. Others hope the controversy will push Carr to be more mindful of his receiver’s positioning and timing, potentially improving the offense’s efficiency and safety.

 

In any case, the Saints will need to put this behind them as they prepare for the next game. While the debate rages on, Carr and the Saints are undoubtedly focused on securing wins and ensuring the health and safety of their players, especially Olave, who remains a vital component of their offensive arsenal. The Saints’ success in the coming weeks may depend heavily on how Carr responds to the growing scrutiny and whether he and Olave can continue to build their chemistry in a way that maximizes performance and minimizes risk.